• »About
  • »FAQ
  • »Contact
  • »Help

Dont Believe Everything You Read in College Admissions Blogs and Forums

Monday, 5 January 2009 11:40 by Melissa

Although it may seem ironic, this week's tip-off is: "Don't Believe Everything You Read in College Admissions Blogs and Forums"

Some students are frantically trying to measure their odds of acceptance in this competitive admissions landscape. "Getting in" (or not) is popular chat material according to the New York Times article entitled "College Admission Angst Finds a Forum on Web". Any reader on a college admission blog or forum can find plenty of students pleading for acceptance predictions based on comparisons of their GPA and test scores with averages from their target colleges.

As you read through posts laden with cries for help, agonies of defeat, and whoops of acceptance celebration, here's a little perspective:

Hard objective data like GPAs and test scores are just part of the picture. The accepted, rejected or "in-limbo" student blogger is subject to a lot of other forces that she may not be considering or highlighting in her post. Remember, some colleges put a lot of stock in geographic recruitment, student character as demonstrated in a subjective essay, and unique talents and interests. Bottom line: Whether the admissions department gave her a thumbs up or thumbs down has very little to do with your chances.

Sometimes, people are not exactly truthful on the web. Even so-called "college admissions experts" may have agendas, so beware. Is the blogger trying to get students to sign up for a paid service? Is he not even in the college services community and just looking to drive web traffic to his site? Watch out and read between the lines. Stick to reputable websites recommended by educators and nonprofit organizations (such as MyCollegeOptions.org), which are more likely to dispense legitimate advice.

If you ever want help evaluating a source, the My College Options® blog team ( Lena , Emily and I) will be more than happy to give you our honest two cents.

Read on my friends, just be careful when talking or listening to strangers. : )

Be the first to rate this post

  • Currently 0/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Tip-Off: Character Counts in College Admissions

Wednesday, 24 December 2008 18:59 by Melissa

I think we would all agree that the college admissions process is a series of evaluations to assemble a "best odds" enrolled student body. Certain measurements, such as GPA and test scores, are hard facts. Let's say that you have made your own predictive mental checklist:

  • Grade point average
  • Test scores
  • AP courses
  • Extracurricular activities

What is missing from the list above? Perhaps, one of the most winning elements: character. Remember, college admissions officers know that you are going to contribute to campus life in either a positive or negative way for the next four years. How are you going to stand out after the hard facts are considered?

You want to be the applicant who shows integrity and has a demonstrated track record of making things better for those around them. How do you show your character? It can be demonstrated through your actions:

  • Why you do things
  • How you choose to do things
  • Who you do things with (Are you more of a "go-it-alone" or "everybody-join-in type"?)

Also, remember: Don't be a showoff that obviously spent a day at the soup kitchen for the purpose of their college application. Do things you're actually interested in or your enthusiasm won't come through when you write your essays. The more passionate you are about an activity, the easier it will be to communicate this on paper or in person (if you get interviewed).

Joyce Slayton Mitchell provides a helpful set of questions in her book, Winning the Heart of the College Admissions Dean, to help you explore your character:

  • What adjectives do I use to describe myself?
  • How would my best friend describe me?
  • Which relationships are most important to me? Why?
  • How free do I feel to make my own decisions?
  • How free do I feel to stand alone from my friends with a decision and point of view different than theirs?
  • How do I feel about going to a college where other students are quite different from me?
  • How do I feel about going to a college very different from my high school?

My advice: Use these character questions above to color your essays and ask those teachers and/or counselors providing recommendations to comment on these areas.

Currently rated 5.0 by 1 people

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Tip-Off: Get Up Close and Personal for a Great Essay

Wednesday, 10 December 2008 15:51 by Melissa
If your college application were a body, your admissions essay would be the face. The essay is your chance to distinguish yourself from other prospective students with a similar bone structure (GPA, academic course history, test scores, etc). As you think about your appearance, remember that you are writing for an audience:  the college admissions officers. They have posed a question and they are looking for a well-formed answer colored by your personality and voice.

Now that you know your essay is an up close shot of your personality, take a moment and identify your angle. Don't just copy and paste the same essay into each college application. Remember, this is a personal communication between you and a unique college admissions department. Pay very close attention to how individual schools phrase the essay question(s), this is the biggest hint that you are going to get! They are reading for a thorough answer with follow-through examples of real life experiences.

Common college essay questions:

Significant Experience- College admissions officers want you to identify an experience that demonstrates your "real life" ability to learn and grow. Be specific and tell a complete story:

  • What led up to the opportunity/event (set the scene)
  • What happened (describe main characters namely yourself and event)
  • What you learned/how you grew (outcome).

Important Issue- College admissions officers are asking you to take a position and think through an issue. Here is your chance to show that you can develop a stance and remain tolerant of the opposing view. It is important to briefly identify the issue and supporting facts then discuss possible viewpoints. Own your viewpoint and recognize any compelling, opposing arguments with rational reasons for why you disagree or only agree in part.

Hint: You may want to steer clear of volatile, high profile social issues that everyone else is likely to discuss. Choose an aspect of an issue that you can own and try to avoid universal issues that may lead to fatal universal statements! 

EssayEdge, a division of Peterson's, provides an excellent essay guide. Just remember that the sample essay structures with fill-in blanks are just that: examples! This is not a Mad-Lib exercise; it is your chance to show your unique face to the people who have the power to accept or deny your application.

Currently rated 4.5 by 2 people

  • Currently 4.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Privacy Statement